Why People Ignore Good Advice (Even When They Need It)

Plus: How to Get People to Actually Listen

Have you ever had that friend who starts every conversation with "I need to tell you something important" (and somehow it's never actually that important)? Or that relative who begins every family gathering with "You know what you should do..." (and somehow you've never once taken their advice)?

Your partners have those people too. And guess what? In their minds, you might be one of them.

The Permission Paradox

You've just discovered the absolute perfect solution to your partner's biggest challenge. You're literally vibrating with excitement. You have charts! Data! ROI calculations that would make a CFO weep with joy!

And somehow, the more enthusiastically you share it, the more your partner's eyes glaze over like a donut at a Monday morning meeting.

It's called reactance theory—that fascinating moment when good information dies in a sea of unsolicited advice (and yes, that statistic about unsolicited advice effectiveness was, ironically, unsolicited).

Why Your Brain Hates Surprise Wisdom

Back in 1966, psychologist Jack Brehm discovered something fascinating: the moment someone feels information is being forced on them, their brain literally starts generating counter-arguments (because apparently, our brains are all secretly debate team captains).

Think about your own reactions:

  • Random LinkedIn connection: "Let me tell you how to run your business!" (You: instantly becomes business expert).

  • Stranger at the gym: "Your form is all wrong!" (You: suddenly remembers you're actually a certified trainer).

  • Partner: "We need to discuss your strategy..." (You: develops immediate and unshakeable conviction in current strategy).

The Three Horsemen of the Info-pocalypse

1. The "Trust Me, I Know Better" Trap

What you think you're saying: "I have valuable insights!"

What they hear: "Everything you're doing is wrong." (Oddly, they weren't asking for a performance review).

2. The "Just Trying to Help" Hustle

What you think you're saying: "I care about your success!"

What they hear: "You're clearly failing without my wisdom." (Fun fact: Nobody has ever calmed down after hearing "I'm just trying to help").

3. The "Quick Suggestion" Quicksand

What you think you're saying: "Here's a simple improvement!"

What they hear: "Let me add seventeen items to your to-do list." (Because somehow "quick" suggestions always require "extensive" implementations).

The Permission Principle

Here's the thing, the exact same information, presented with permission, gets processed in an entirely different part of the brain. It's like the difference between choosing to eat a vegetable and having someone force-feed you kale (which, let's be honest, is always a crime against humanity).

⚠️ Reality Check: You're probably sharing way more unsolicited information than you realize. Each "quick update" or "helpful suggestion" is training your partners to tune you out faster than a toddler being told it's nap time (and we all know how well that usually goes).

Power Moves for Permission-Based Partnership

1. The Curiosity Catalyst

Instead of: "Let me tell you what I've noticed..."

Try: "What patterns are you seeing in...?" (Because people love their own insights more than your observations).

2. The Permission Path

Instead of: "You should really consider..."

Try: "Would you be interested in exploring...?" (Turns out people like having a choice about receiving your wisdom. Who knew?).

3. The Value Validation

Instead of: "I have something that could help..."

Try: "What kind of information would be most valuable right now?" (Pro tip: Sometimes the most valuable thing you can share is silence).

AI Learning Lab: The Permission Protocol

Transform your partner communications from unsolicited advice into welcomed insights with this prompt:

Analyze partnership communication for permission patterns:

Input:
- Recent partner communications
- Meeting transcripts
- Training materials
- Strategy documents

Output:
1. Permission Gap Analysis:
   - Identify assumption points
   - Flag information pushes
   - Highlight missed permission opportunities

2. Engagement Architecture:
   - Permission-seeking sequences
   - Value validation checkpoints
   - Partner-led discovery moments

3. Response Optimization:
   - Permission-based templates
   - Curiosity-driven frameworks
   - Value validation workflows

The most valuable information in the world is worthless if shared at the wrong moment (just ask anyone who's ever been given relationship advice by their parents).

P.S. You had full permission to ignore this entire email. How did that make you want to read it more? Psychology is fun that way.

Let’s hear it!

What’s your take on today’s email? Your feedback makes these better, so don’t hold back.

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.